By: Eric Candela, Government Relations Director & Emily Hubbard, Government Relations Intern
Access to food assistance programs designed to help people out of poverty is based on a household’s income relative to the Federal Poverty Limit (FPL). Only 15 percent of households in the tri-county area are living below the poverty threshold according to the U.S. Census Bureau; and yet the 2026 ALICE data for metro Detroit showed that 40 percent of households struggle to afford daily necessities.
What accounts for the difference, and what does it mean for the additional 25 percent of households forgotten in the official metric?
The Official Poverty Measure (OPM) is based on a 1950’s study by the U.S. Department of Agriculture that estimated families spent one-third of their income on their food budget. The annual cost of food for an emergency food budget – not a healthy, nutritionally balanced one – was estimated to be $1,000 in 1963. This $1,000 estimate was multiplied by a factor of three so that the Federal Poverty Level was originally set at $3,000 for a family of four in 1965. It has increased at the rate of inflation over the years. Today, the FPL for a family of four is $33,000.
There are several problems with the FPL which make it outdated and ineffective for accurately estimating the point at which people do not have enough money to purchase basic life necessities.
• Living standards have changed considerably since 1955 as the relative cost of housing and health care has soared. Childcare and internet connectivity have become essential costs for most families that were not considered when creating the OPM. Transportation costs have increased as a percentage of a household’s budget. Ironically, the cost of food, as a percentage of a family’s budget, has decreased slightly.
• The FPL is based on pre-tax earnings even though many wage earners receive paychecks with taxes already withheld. The FPL incorporates earnings many families have no access to.
• The FPL is the same in Detroit as it is in Dallas, Sacramento or Miami, irrespective of the local cost of living.
The FPL is 84.3 percent lower than the current median income level for the Wayne-Oakland-Macomb region, and alternative standards, like ALICE, suggest that it should be even higher than the median. Until the FPL is adjusted to account for present-day living circumstances, struggling families will continue to have too much income to qualify for food assistance but not enough to fill their shopping carts unless and until adjustments are made to the FPL. A dangerous and disheartening paradox.
